(Kitco News) - The proposed capital gains tax increases in the U.S. and Canada could significantly dampen economic vitality and stifle innovation, potentially altering the landscape for entrepreneurs and investors, according to Daryl Ching, a Chartered Financial Analyst and Managing Partner at Vistance Capital Advisory.
In a recent interview with Jeremy Szafron, Anchor at Kitco News, Ching detailed the complexities and potential economic impact of the proposed tax strategies.
"The 25% on unrealized gains is a much bigger issue," Ching explained while discussing Biden’s proposed tax changes for the US, "because what that means is even if you don't sell your investment in the short term and you still hold on to it but you have an unrealized gain, meaning the market value has gone up by a certain amount, you can still get taxed on it even though you haven't sold the asset yet."
This aspect of the tax proposal could fundamentally shift financial strategies for the wealthy, affecting how investments are managed and potentially leading to less long-term holding of volatile or high-appreciation assets.
In Canada, the proposed changes are set to increase the inclusion rate for capital gains over $250,000 from one-half to two-thirds, affecting both individuals and corporations.
"Canada’s now shot up to 33%. So effectively, you are now paying 10% more on capital gains in Canada than you are in the U.S. on a long-term investment," Ching said.
For what it will mean for Canada’s economic growth, watch the video above.
The response from specific professional groups like doctors and entrepreneurs adds another layer of concern.
The Canadian Medical Association has warned that the tax changes could adversely affect healthcare provision, potentially reducing service levels or pushing professionals to relocate their practices. Entrepreneurs echoed these sentiments, with the Canadian Federation of Independent Business highlighting how the changes could make the business environment less favorable and discourage investment.
Ching elaborated on the entrepreneurial challenges. "If you look at the entrepreneur, a lot of us that start businesses don't start wealthy. In fact, we often have to put up our life savings. Sometimes we go into debt to start a business in the hope of making a successful exit in the future, where 90% of businesses fail. And, you know, when you look into what entrepreneurs go through, we get into situations where we have to stop paying ourselves. Sometimes we have to mortgage, do a second mortgage or take out more debt in order to continue paying our employees to keep the lights on."
Ching pointed to the broader implications of such tax increases, emphasizing the risks they pose not just to the wealthy but to the entire economic ecosystem.
For more on the differences between the U.S. and Canada proposals, watch the video above.